Wednesday, 7 December 2011

Does anonymity breed cruelty?

I just saw the very powerful You tube video posted a few days ago by a Jonah Mowry (already over 6 million people have watched it).



I don’t want to comment on the video – it speaks for itself. What I want to address are some of the comments that the video has received. 

It is difficult for me (and I am a psychiatrist and am supposed to understand these things) to read so many cruel comments (I will not dignify them by repeating them here). Why are so many people posting such cruel and vicious comments? Are so many people by nature so cruel and so vicious? Is this a phenomenon that is encouraged by the medium of electronic communication? Is this a reflection of levels of homophobia so deeply rooted in our society? Is this the result of anxiety aroused by seeing a young person in distress? Why the anger?

I have no answers to these questions. But I do know that such cruel and vicious comments are wrong. There is no place for such cruelty towards others in our society. Trying to understand why however does not excuse us from taking action to stop such cruelty. This is an obligation from all of us. From those who control the electronic world – there should be no e-space for such attack. From those who are teachers and coaches and parents – we have to stand firm and make it clear that there is no social space for such attack. For peer and friends and all young people – you have to stand up and make it clear that there is no teen space for such attack.

The sooner we get our sh*t together on this, the better for all of us.


-Stan

Thursday, 1 December 2011

Is it boys or is it ADHD?

In recent years it has become fashionable in some circles for people to equate ADHD with being a boy. The lack of understanding about what ADHD is, or what is different about being a boy with ADHD from a boy without ADHD does not seem to give pause to certainty of their opinions.  Just last week, I was subjected to one of these passionate diatribes by a Professor teaching in a division of health human resources about the “medicalization of childhood” (his words, not mine).  When I gently reminded him about the brain imaging research on ADHD, his response was not with interest in what had been found, but in denying its importance completely.  “Everyone knows boys are driven by their emotions,” was his reply.  Strange, the last time I checked emotional regulation was a brain function.

 A recent study reported in the June 2011 edition of the Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry (Neuroanatomical and neurophsyological correlates of the cerebellum in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder – combined type) has added new and more detailed information about brain structures in children who have ADHD.  In this study, the researchers found that a particular brain structure, called the posterior inferior vermis was significantly smaller in children with ADHD than in controls. A  finding that is consistent with a fairly large number of studies demonstrating cerebellar differences in young people with ADHD.  As the cerebellum is important for impulse control, shifting of attention and motor coordination, these finding are very important for they may explain in part many of the symptoms found in ADHD.  A collateral finding, that medications which are effective in treating ADHD impact this part of the brain, lends further support for this consideration.

So what does all this mean for the opinionated Professor and his dogmatic but uniformed certainty?  Perhaps it is time to start teaching neurodevelopment in all human services training programs.   If you are studying to be a social worker, a teacher, a psychologist, a child and youth worker, a nurse, a doctor, etc., you need to know neurodevelopment and understand how brain function underlies human experience, emotions and behavior.   While it may be too late for us to change the Professor’s stigma, the worse since it is cloaked in profundity and ignorance while concurrently enjoying the status of his position, we may be able to encourage reason and curiosity in the next generation of teachers, health providers and professors.

--Stan

Wednesday, 13 July 2011

A Global Opportunity to Advance Mental Health: Can we grasp it?


September 2011 will be an important month for many different reasons. One reason will be especially important for improving mental health across the globe. The United Nations will be holding a special session on Non-Communicable Diseases in New York that month. The purpose of that meeting is to encourage a global response to these diseases, and mental disorders are at the top of the list of diseases causing the greatest burden of illness worldwide. Unfortunately, mental disorders are not at the top of the list of the conveners of this special session. As we are all too familiar, mental disorders are too often not on the list when it comes to health care investment – not only here in Canada but around the world.

We know how important mental health is – in wealthy and in poor countries. It is well documented that mental disorders can lead to poverty, decreased educational attainment, job difficulties, incarceration and a poorer quality of life. They increase the risk for substance abuse (including alcohol and tobacco), a variety of physical illnesses and poor adherence to treatment for a number of different illnesses – including HIV-Aids. Mental disorders are very costly, in both direct (for example, hospital beds) and indirect (for example, decreased work productivity) ways. Effective and cost efficient treatments are available and have recently been catalogued and widely distributed to health providers across the globe by the World Health Organization (if you are interested, google mhGAP). What is now needed is to get mental health on the global health agenda.

And we need your help to do this.


Write your Provincial Minister of Health and the Federal Minister of Health and your local member of Provincial and Federal Parliament. Tell them that you would like them to bring this issue forward at this very important meeting. Ask your friends and neighbors to do the same. Not only may this have an impact at the global level, but it may help in your Province and in Canada as well!

Monday, 11 July 2011

Helping Early May Help in Unexpected Ways

Our team has been doing some interesting work in school mental health for a few years now. Much of it has been focused on enhancing mental health literacy for teens (through a secondary school curriculum) and teachers (through a variety of different mental health for educators training programs) as well as facilitating early identification and effective treatment for young people who have a mental disorder – such as depression, panic disorder; etc. While the potential mental health benefits of early identification and effective treatment are relatively easy to understand, there are other benefits that may be less evident but also very important. One area of such benefit is found in relation to a number of physical illnesses: diabetes; heart disease and maybe even some forms of cancer!

We have known for some time now that mental disorders are risk factors for a number of other illnesses. That means that the presence of a mental disorder (such as depression) can increase the probability that a person will develop another illness (such as diabetes). There is also some evidence that suggests that having a mental disorder following the onset of another illness, such as heart disease, increases risk for early death from that disease. Although there are many hypotheses about why this may happen, we do not yet really know how this happens and research into understanding how this may happen is currently under-way. Did you know that the same brain chemical that is involved in controlling mood (serotonin) may also be involved in controlling how platelets clump together in the blood? Could it be that problems with serotonin function in the brain can result in depression and at the same time may make blood clotting (which could lead to strokes or heart attacks) more of a problem? Ongoing research may help us better understand this issue.

So, it may also be that if we can better identify, diagnose and effectively treat young people when they first develop a mental disorder, we may also be able to decrease the risk of them developing another illness – such as heart disease, diabetes and perhaps even some forms of cancer. Or, if not that, maybe early and effective treatment of mental disorders might delay the onset of another illness or maybe improve treatment outcomes. Right now we do not really know the answers to these questions but being aware of this possibility is really important for us – both personally and for public health reasons.


Secondary prevention, meaning the prevention of another illness by effective treatment of a pre-existing disorder, of some physical illnesses might be achieved by early effective treatment of a mental disorder during the teenage years. This is an exciting possibility! Will this pan out? We don’t know yet. But, to my way of thinking, there is enough evidence on this possibility already available to further underscore the need to better identify, diagnose and treat mental disorders in young people. We know what needs to be done – now we only have got to get our act together and do it!

Thursday, 7 July 2011

The Academy in Mental Health for Educators: A new opportunity

We have been working in the area of school mental health for some years now and have created a variety of programs and educational resources for educators, health providers, youth and parents. Over and over again we have heard from teachers, social workers, psychologists, nurses, principals, school superintendents and others about the need to provide more training for educators in the area of youth mental health and a better understanding of youth mental disorders. Over and over again we have heard that a summer program would be a good venue in which this could be done. So guess what – we listened and decided to do exactly that. Our first Academy in Mental Health for Educators will start next week – in Halifax, Nova Scotia. As far as we know, this is the first event of its kind ever in the Atlantic Provinces.

So what will happen at this Academy. First, it will take place over a two day period – actually two such two day periods. The first will be on a Monday/Tuesday and the second, on a Thursday/Friday will be a repeat of the first session.   There are a variety of different topics to be covered. These range from detailed information about common mental disorders in youth to advice on how to talk to teens and parents to understanding medications and their role in treatment to specific “classroom pearls” for helping young people who are living with a mental disorder be more successful in the school setting. Participants will also be exposed to a variety of useful and effective educational materials and programs.

We are really excited about the program and our presenters. In addition to key members of our Sun Life Financial Chair in Adolescent Mental Health Team, presenters will include psychiatrists; psychologists; teachers and others who work with youth, families and educators. We hope that the program will be fun and informative for all who attend. One of the fun components will be a “Halifax dine around” evening where participants can sign up to join one of the presenters for dinner at one of the many excellent restaurants in the city. Not only may people discover a great new place to eat, but they will have the chance to chat to an expert in the field – and hopefully that will be both fun and informative!
As always, we will be evaluating how the Academy turns out. Not only in terms of participant satisfaction and improvement suggestions but also in terms of learning that has happened during the sessions. And, as always, we will be posting the results of this learning on our website. Frankly, I am both a bit excited and a bit nervous about this. What if our learning evaluation does not show a significant positive impact of the session on participants’ mental health knowledge? Or horrors of horrors, what if it shows a negative impact on participants’ mental health knowledge? At best that would be so embarrassing.


--Stan

Thursday, 26 May 2011

Helping Students with ADHD Achieve Success: Tips for Teachers


ADHD impacts approximately 5-10% of children, which means as a teacher, 1 in 10 students may present with ADHD symptoms. It can seem like a handful with students squirming, drifting off in space, and disturbing others around them. But it doesn’t have to be.

As a teacher you are in a unique position to help the student learn habits at school that will help them be successful in their home and with them as they move through the education system.  Assisting young people with ADHD to learn how to feel and think better about themselves, and to identify and build on their strengths can be an important step in helping them control their symptoms of ADHD. Students with ADHD need to learn how to cope with daily problems and control their attention as well as their impulsivity, teachers and parents need to work together to help students achieve this success.

Tips for teachers:

·         Encourage youth to ‘stop and think’. This could take the form of counting to 3 before asking a                 question, or writing the question down and asking it at the proper time.

·         Create a token reward system – where emphasis is placed on the positive outcomes of behaving           appropriately.

·         Help your students have a regular routine. Posting the routine, reminding them of homework at               the end of the day, use organizers to help them keep their days straight.

·         Post rules in the classroom where they are easy to see and adhere to. Out of sight, is out of                   mind.

·         Helping kids who distract easily involves physical placement, increased movement, and breaking             long work into shorter chunks.

·         Post the day’s schedule each day at the front of the room, and cross of items as they are done.             Young people with impulse problems may gain a sense of control and feel calmer when they know           what to expect.

·         Be brief when giving instructions. Breaking them into bite sized chunks by asking the student to               do one step, and then tell them the next step once the first is completed, will help all students, but           especially those with ADHD

·         Incorporate physicality into learning by giving students opportunities to act out stories, or sing                 songs. Providing them with outlets for their physical energy.

Students with ADHD are often easily distracted and can become that way even in mid-sentence. If you do not know what they are talking about, ask them to help you understand. When speaking with a student, it’s best to not assume you know what a young person is going through (unless you yourself have struggled with ADHD) and instead ask them to tell you what it’s like, and what they need from you to help them be successful.

Meet with parents and talk about their son/daughter’s treatment as well as tactics and techniques they use at home. If you can reinforce successful tactics at home and school, you create an increasingly familiar routine for the student. Rewards programs can extend beyond the classroom and into the home life if a parent and teacher can work closely.

Each student will be different, so developing a toolkit of strategies that you can use with each child will help you find the best fit for them. Make sure to talk to other teachers and parents, to share great ideas and success stories.


--Stan Kutcher, MD, FRCPC and Christina Carew, ABC

Wednesday, 25 May 2011

How do I talk to my teenager about suicide?

One of the issues that arise in discussions with parents about youth mental health is: “how do I talk to my teenager about suicide?" This is most often in the context of a media report about a youth suicide or a community or school experience of youth suicide. There is no “right” way to discuss this issue but there are some useful guideposts.

Be prepared to chat if your teen brings it up but do not be surprised if that does not happen. If you have concerns that your teen may want to discuss this you can address the issue in a gentle and “just putting it out there” manner. Saying something such as: “I was reading in the paper about the young person who recently died. Sounds like a tragic situation” can be an ice-breaker. Then if your teen is interested, they have an opportunity to discuss it with you. Sometimes they will be interested and sometimes they will not be interested. Or, they may bring it up at a later time, when they are ready.

If, however, you or your teen knows the person who had died, then this discussion should be explicit. This is now not an issue of “talking” to your teen, but an issue of grieving while at the same time acknowledging that death was by suicide. There can be a tendency to both avoid the issue of suicide or to over-focus on the issue of suicide. Try not to do either. 

Sometimes both you and your teen may need more support than usual (such as family and friends or religious communities). If this is the case, you can seek out services that are available through your local community health center or mental health care providers. A useful resource is the booklet “Have you lost someone to suicide?” which is available on this website here.

If you are concerned that your teen is having a mental health problem or may be depressed, it is a good idea when you are discussing this to bring the issue closer to home. There is nothing wrong with acknowledging that depression or a mental health problem increases risk for suicide and making that knowledge part of what you monitor when your teen is not feeling well. If you have diabetes you monitor your blood sugar and your diet. If you have depression you monitor your mood and thoughts about suicide.



-Stan